THE SECOND MARINE DIVISION IN
WORLD WAR II

"The Silent Second"

 

PART IVd. TARAWA — OBJECTIVE SECURED

 

I turn to the big red-bearded Marine gunner who is standing beside me and say, "What a hell of a way to die!" The gunner looks me in the eye and says, "You can't pick a better way."

Robert Sherrod, Tarawa, The Story of a Battle

 

November 22nd, 1943 dawned clear and hot across Tarawa atoll. On the main island of the atoll, codenamed "Helen," every Marine who fought there would remember the smell for the rest of his life. It was an indescribable stench of putrefying corpses, rotten food, and other odors to vile to think about. And the air was clogged with the dust and smoke of battle. The smell permeated everything, clothing, food, hair, skin. It was the odor of death, of the charnel house. Nevertheless, the Marines of the Second Division—bloodied, numbed, thirsty—strapped on their gear and moved into the assault.

The morning began with an attack at 0700 by Landing Team 1/8. Supported by three light tanks of Company C, 2nd Tank Battalion, 1/8 was ordered to clear the boundary between Beaches red 1 and Red 2. Several redoubtable Japanese pillboxes remained intact in this area, and they proved to be too tough for the tanks, which were withdrawn late in the morning after one was knocked out by a magnetic mine. In the book Tarawa, the Story of a Battle, war correspondent Robert Sherrod described the Japanese defensive works:

"Here, a hundred yards from the beach, is the type of fortification that has withstood this awful pounding for two days, and it is no wonder! Double thicknesses of eight-inch-thick coconut logs, hooked together with steel spikes, buttressed by upright logs driven far in the ground, covered by three feet of shrapnel absorbing sand. The pillbox cannot be built altogether underground because water lies four to six feet under the surface on Betio, so it is half underground and half above ground."

So, the infantry Marines and combat engineers resorted to the proven methods of bangalore torpedoes, shaped charges, and flamethrowers to destroy the fortifications. It was a slow and methodical process that took most of the day. As the day wore on, Companies A and C made good progress. But Company B was held in position by intense enemy fire.

The tanks were replaced by two 75mm halftracks of the 2nd Marines Heavy Weapons Company. These vehicles immediately received a heavy volume of enemy fire directed against them. One was forced to pull back when its' radiator was damaged. Although the attack achieved little in the way of ground won, it led to the destruction of several enemy strong points. Late in the afternoon, a small Japanese counterattack formed in 1/8's area, but the Marines repulsed it with little trouble.

Marines engage a group of Japanese troops in a split second firefight on Tarawa. Still image from USMC combat camera film


At 0800, Landing Team 1/6, under Maj William K. Jones, kicked off the attack eastward along Helen's southern shore. With nearly a full complement of men and equipment, 1/6 made good progress through the morning in a zone of attack little more than 100 yards wide. Jones' Marines secured over a thousand yards of ground, killing about 250 Japanese troops in the process. They were supported by M3 light tanks of 3rd Platoon, Company B, 2nd Tank Battalion. At 1100 LT 1/6 linked up with the embattled Marines of Landing Team 1/2, and then reorganized to continue the attack at 1330. The battalion's direct support was increased when it received more tanks, for a total of seven M3s and an M4 medium tank. During the afternoon's fighting, LT 1/6 covered an additional 700 yards, killing over 200 enemy defenders.

Among the heroic Marines in 1/6 was 1stLt Hugh D. Fricks, of Seattle, Washington. He received a posthumous Navy Cross for his gallantry in the attack on 22 November 1943. His citation read in part:

"Defying constant danger from enemy machine-gun and mortar fire while advancing with his battalion, 1stLt Fricks conducted various reconnaissances, maintained contact between forward rifle elements and went from foxhole to foxhole pointing out targets and directing machine-gun fire. Tirelessly continuing his perilous task until mortally wounded by an enemy grenade later in the action, he served as an inspiring example to his battalion in delivering a devastating blow to Japanese forces in that sector."

From their positions near Red beach 3 oriented generally eastward, Landing Team 2/8, commanded by the tough Maj Jim Crowe, launched a concerted assault against three mutually-supported Japanese emplacements. The attack got off to a lucky start when an 81mm mortar round made a perfect hit on one of the emplacements, detonating the ammunition stored inside. The titanic blast completely destroyed the bunker. Another of the positions received effective fire from 1stLt Lou Largey's M4 medium tank Colorado. This left only the large Japanese bombproof near the Burns-Philps wharf.

The attack was supported by combat engineers of the 18th Marines. Their officer, 1stLt Alexander Bonnyman, led them in the face of stout resistance to the top of the bombproof, the highest point on the island. The Japanese resisted fiercely, counterattacking the beleaguered Marines. His posthumous Medal of Honor citation recorded 1stLt Bonnyman's final minutes of life:

"[H]e led his men in a renewed assault, fearlessly exposing himself to the merciless slash of hostile fire as he stormed the formidable bastion, directed the placement of demolition charges in both entrances and seized the top of the bombproof position, flushing more than 100 of the enemy who were instantly cut down, and effecting the annihilation of approximately 150 troops inside the emplacement. Assailed by additional Japanese after he had gained his objective, he made a heroic stand on the edge of the structure, defending his strategic position with indomitable determination in the face of the desperate charge and killing 3 of the enemy before he fell, mortally wounded."

William Bonnyman's heroic sacrifice was not in vain. As the Japanese defenders rushed from the bombproof, they were cut down by weapons of every caliber from rifles to 37mm antitank guns of the 2nd Marines Regimental Weapons Company. The position was completely neutralized when a Seabee bulldozer came forward under heavy fire support and sealed the entrances with sand, preventing any escape for the defenders trapped inside.

1stLt Bonnyman's assault force of combat engineers during the fighting on the Japanese bombproof. Still image from USMC combat camera film

 

During the course of the attack, LT 2/8 drove forward to the eastern edge of the airfield, to a point where it was endangered by encroaching fire from the advance of Landing Team 1/6 on the southern shore. Maj Crowe therefore pulled his front lines back about 150 yards as his Marines progressed with the dirty and dangerous job of mopping up the areas they had just secured.

Robert Sherrod captured the feeling of the grinding and deadly fighting on D+2:

"To the awful symphony of the big guns is added the crackling fire fire of hundreds of Marines and several pillboxes full of well-hidden Japs. Marines dart across the expanses of the airfield while machine gun and snipers' rifles kick up dust around them. They dodge from shellhole to shellhole as they advance toward the enemy. One Marine is wounded but drags himself the remaining ten feet to a shellhole, where eager hands pull him out of further danger. On the other side of the runway a medium tank, looking like a great big, clumsy bug, lumbers up to a pillbox and begins blasting away, from less than 50 feet, round after round of 75mm shells. A Jap, naked except for his white G-string cloth, runs out of the pillbox and throws himself under the tread of the tank. There is a small explosion as the Jap's hand grenade goes off, but his suicide nets him nothing except his idea of a warrior's heaven. The grenade does not even blow the tank's tread off. The tank lumbers over the Jap, still firing."


Two Marines survey the blasted wreckage on Tarawa. Still image from USMC combat camera film


During the morning of D+2 another intact battalion landed on Betio. This was Landing Team 3/6, commanded by LtCol Kenneth McLeod. LT 3/6 had spent an uncomfortable night floating off the island in landing boats. Finally making it ashore at around 1100, McLeod and his Marines were ordered to follow in trace behind Maj Jones' Landing Team 1/6. At evening approached, LT 3/6 dug in about 600 yards behind the forward lines of LT 1/6.

That afternoon, division commander MajGen Julian Smith came ashore from his command post aboard the USS Maryland to take control of the battle. Even now, the run-in to the beach head was hazardous, and the driver of Smith's amphibian tractor was wounded during ship-to-shore movement. Once established, Smith assumed tactical command of the battle from Col Edson. At 1601, Smith sent the following situation report to the Maryland:

"Situation not favorable for rapid clean-up of Betio. Heavy casualties among officers make leadership problem difficult. Still strong, organized resistance [vicinity eastern end of the airfield.] Many emplacements intact on eastern end of the island. Present front line approximately on the western edge of [map coordinates] 214, 236, and 212. In addition, many Japanese strong points to westward of our front lines within our position that have not been reduced. Progress slow and extremely costly. Complete occupation will take at least 5 more days. Naval and air bombardment a great help but does not take out emplacements."

As night approached, the Second Marine Division, battered, bloody, and bruised, had about 7,000 Marines ashore, opposed by roughly 1,000 surviving Japanese defenders. About two-thirds of Betio's landmass was now in American hands, leaving the Japanese garrison trapped on the island's eastern tail. Marine artillery and naval gunfire were now relentlessly pounding the enemy positions. Progress on D+2 had been slow, methodical, and Marines literally paid for each piece of newly-won ground in blood. Progress in the attack did not bode well for a speedy end to the fighting, but then something happened that would dramatically shorten the fight for Tarawa.

NIGHTTIME BANZAI ATTACKS

During the night of 22-23 November 1943, the remaining Japanese defenders launched a series of futile, suicidal Banzai attacks against the Marine defenses. The first occurred at around 1930, when a group of 50 Japanese troops attacked the defenses of Landing Team 1/6. In this preliminary attack, the Japanese initially opened a small gap in the Marine lines, but the enemy was destroyed when Marine reserve units came forward to seal the breach. Another attack developed against LT 1/6 at around 2300, and was again repulsed by the Marines.

Fighting continued sporadically in the LT 1/6 sector as the night drug on. Then at around 0400 on 23 November, an estimated 300 Japanese launched an all-out assault on Companies A and B. In this urgent situation, forward observer 1stLT N. E. Milner called in 75mm howitzer fire to within 75 yards of the Marine defenses, and the destroyers USS Schroeder and USS Sigsbee fired from the lagoon non-stop at Japanese troop concentrations. Richard W. Johnston described the drama of this action in Follow Me! The Story of the Second Marine Division in World War II:

"The Marines fought back silently and savagely, but the weight of the Jap attack swelled until Lieutenant Norman B. Thomas, acting commander of B Company, telephoned battalion: "We are killing them as fast as they come at us, but we can't hold much longer: we need reinforcements!" There was no time to move up reinforcements. [Maj] Jones told Thomas: "You've got to hold!" Somehow, the Marines of B Company held ...

It was over in one endless, agonizing hour. The Marines greeted the breaking dawn with haunted eyes, and tired but proud words: "They told us to hold... and by God, we held.""

Pvt Jack Stambaugh, a rifleman in Company B, was one of the men who stood in the face of this onslaught. . His posthumous Navy Cross citation told of his courageous actions:

"Observing four Japanese soldiers attacking a wounded Marine in an isolated position during the height of a fierce enemy night counterattack, Private Stambaugh unhesitatingly risked his life to race to the aid of his helpless comrade and, closing in for a brief, savage encounter, killed all four of the enemy with his rifle and bayonet before succumbing to a neck wound inflicted by a saber-wielding Japanese officer."

By dawn's early light, 300 Japanese corpses lay heaped in front of the Marine lines. MajGen Smith had followed the unfolding action, and he now passed the orders for the final push. The enemy's back was broken, and divisional elements attacked relentlessly through the morning of D+3. At 1310, Landing Team 3/6 reached the eastern tip of Betio, and organized resistance was finished. But mop-up—the filthy, dangerous job of rooting out the last enemy hold-outs—continued for two days. Out of more than 5,000 Japanese defenders, Marines ultimately only took 146 prisoners, most of whom were Korean forced laborers. Only 17 living Japanese were captured on Betio, the majority badly wounded.

A Marine is evacuated under fire during the fighting on Tarawa. War correspondent Robert Sherrod wrotein his diary during the battle: "If a sign of certain victory were needed... this is it. The jeeps have arrived."   Still image from USMC combat camera film


Vth Amphibious Corps commander LtGen Holland M. Smith came ashore on 23 November 1943 to visit the division, and to see for himself what had transpired on the island called Helen. He later recorded some of his impressions in Coral and Brass:

"As I stepped ashore from the barge to the jetty inside the lagoon on my way to Julian Smith's Command Post, I passed boys who had lived yesterday a thousand times and looked older than their fathers. Dirty, unshaven, with gaunt, almost sightless eyes, they had survived the ordeal, but it had chilled their souls. There were no smiles on these ancient, youthful faces; only passive relief among the dead."

And so, the battle of Betio came to a close. The airfield, scene of so much bloodshed, was quickly repaired and improved by Marine engineers and Seabees. It was christened Hawkins Field, after the indomitable 1stLt Hawkins of the 2nd Marine Scout-Sniper Platoon. And on the morning of 24 November 1943, transports slipped into the lagoon to carry away the survivors of the 2nd and 8th Marines. In the bright noontime sunshine, the American flag and the British Union Jack were raised in a simple ceremony.

But the fighting for Tarawa Atoll was not yet over. Marines of Landing Team 2/6, under their commander LtCol Raymond Murray, had begun a long hike up the atoll's eastern spine starting on 25 November 1943 to clear Japanese defenders from the atoll's outlying islands. World War II Marine Leon Uris captured the feeling of this landscape in his novel Battle Cry:

"The tinyness of these islands was amazing. Like their bastard cousin, Betio, the islands were long and narrow, running like a chain with links of water between them. They varied in length from several yards to several miles. the width was seldom more than a few hundred yards. Opposite the calm lagoon side was the sharp cragged coral pounded by a heavy surf from the ocean."

LT 2/6 finally found the Japanese dug-in on the small island of Buariki. The Marines made first contact with the enemy on the evening of 26 November 1943. The next morning, the attack resumed, ultimately crushing the enemy garrison completely. Divisional elements also secured other islands as part of Operation GALVANIC. by 1 December 1943, this phase of the operation was completed, and MajGen Smith turned over command of Tarawa to the Navy on 4 December 1943. Two days later, Time Magazine made note of the battle:

"Last week some 2,000 to 3,000 United States Marines, most of them now dead or wounded, gave the nation a name to stand beside those of Concord bridge, the Bon Homme Richard, the Alamo, Little Big Horn, and Belleau Wood. The name was Tarawa."

The American flag is raised over Betio for the first time on 24 November 1943. Still image from USMC combat camera film

 

THE RECKONING

Tarawa was an expensive victory for the Second Marine Division. In the final tally, the division suffered 3,305 Marine casualties, and 85 casualties to attached Naval medical personnel. But the battle not only secured an important airfield, but also validated important tactical doctrines that would figure prominently in future campaigns on the drive to Tokyo. But, that was all in the future for the division. It would be nicknamed "the Silent Second," for its' sacrificial nights on Tarawa. It's new home, on the island of Hawaii, would be named Camp Tarawa, in honor of the fallen. And soon, telegrams begin arriving at the doors of 3,390 Marines and sailors of the Second Marine Division. And the American people got their first glimpses in theaters of the fighting on Tarawa. Marine combat cameramen had accompanied the assault forces, and their work was used to create the color motion picture With the Marines at Tarawa. This gritty look at the battle won the Academy Award for Best Documentary in 1945 and showed the public for the first time the true nature of the war.

The price of victory at Tarawa. Still image from USMC combat camera film

 

But the Marines of Tarawa were not mourned in just the United States. During almost a year spent in New Zealand, the young Americans had developed strong ties with the Kiwis. Although the Second Marine Division never returned to the wonderful land down under, its' Marines would write so much to New Zealand, that for the rest of the war, as much mail would be sent there as to the United States.

It took weeks for the first death notifcations to reach Wellington, and soon the newspaper was filled with lists of Marines killed on Tarawa. The people were shocked and saddened by the loss of so many young men who they had come to know and love. For a long time after the war ended, New Zealanders who continue to commemorate the young Americans who had meant so much to them. One Kiwi faithfully submitted a tribute to the Wellington newspaper each year on the anniversary of the battle. It said:

"United States Marine Corps: To the undying memory of the men of the Second Division who fell at Tarawa, Nov. 20, 1943. In silence we will remember them."

 

Shipboard funeral service for a Marine killed in the assault on Tarawa. Still image from USMC combat camera film

 

EPITAPH AT THE GATE OF THE SECOND MARINE DIVISION CEMETERY ON BETIO ISLAND

By Capt Donald Jackson, USMC

To you, who lie within this coral sand,
We, who remain, pay tribute of a pledge,
That dying, thou shalt surely not have died in vain.
That when again bright morning dyes the sky
And waving fronds above shall touch the rain,
We give you this—that in those times
We will remember.We lived and fought together, thou and we,
And sought to keep the flickering torch aglow
That all our loved ones might forever know
The blessed warmth exceeding flame,
The everlasting scourge of bondsman's chains,
Liberty and light.When we with loving hands laid back the earth
That was for moments short to couch thy form,
We did not bid a last and sad farewell
But only, "Rest ye well."
Then with this humble, heartfelt epitaph
That pays thy many virtues and acclaim
We marked this spot, and murm'ring requiem,
Moved on to westward.

 

 

CASUALTIES TABLES FOR THE ASSAULT ON TARAWA

 
Marine officers
Marine enlisted
Navy FMF officers
Navy FMF enlisted
Killed in action
47
790
2
28
Wounded-killed
2
32
0
0
Died of Wounded
8
82
0
0
Missing, presumed dead
0
27
0
0
Wounded, missing dead
0
2
0
0
Wounded in action
110
2,186
2
57
Combat fatigue
1
14
Subtotal
168
3,133
4
85
Grand total
3,390

NOTES:

1. Marine casualties extracted from Appendix B (page 72) of The Battle for Tarawa, by Capt James Stockman, USMC.
2. Navy casualties extracted from Appendix H (page 636) of History of USMC Operations in World War II , by Henry Shaw, Jr., and refer only to Navy medical personnel attached or assigned to the Second Marine Division.

Men of the Second Marine Division present arms during the flag raising ceremony on Betio, 24 November 1943. Still image from USMC combat camera film

 



PART V. ONWARD TO THE MARIANAS

SECOND MARINE DIVISION INDEX

WORLD WAR II GYRENE HOME

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

This site is owned & maintained by Mark Flowers, copyright 2004, all rights reserved.