"It is one thing to stand on a well-policed firing point on a nice spring day and carefully aim in at a nice round, black bullseye superimposed on a lovely white background. It is quite another to run up a hill, stumble over a log, fall into a water filled shell crater, then aim in with a palsied hand at an erratically moving target which would just as soon exchange a few with you in transit.
The pistol carriers will argue that it is better to be inadequately armed than not to be armed at all. The odd thing is that you occasionally run across ex-pistol carriers who gave gotten tangled up in a few torrid skirmishes. Significantly, they're always carrying carbines or rifles…
A pistol carries about half as much ammunition as a carbine… This means you are obliged to change magazines twice as often for the same amount of fire.
Maximum effective range is all with the carbine… [T]he maximum effective range of a pistol in combat [is] five to seven yards… They both jam on occasion, but the pistol has more functional jams… Neither of them takes any prizes as "brush cutters" or penetrators, but in this field too the carbine has the advantage.
Arms For Officers
anonymous
Marine Corps Gazette
November 1944